I apologize for being so, so, so long in posting on my blog. I have been very busy. Basically it was last November, 2010 that I returned to the classroom. Seeing how my last post was Oct. 2010, this seems to me to be the logical reason for my long delay, now that I see this.
In any case the following is something I wrote recently in response to an article I read in the Fall, 2011 issue of Reform Judaism magazine. The website is reformjudaismmag.org. You can find the article “Lennonism vs. Judaism” in the archives if you wish to see and read the actual article which I am responding to here:
I was unpleasantly stunned to read Ze’ev Maghen’s piece “Lennonism vs. Judaism.” Ze’ev criticizes the song Imagine, which remains a classic in spite of critics such as Ze’ev. Hence I read Ze’ev Maghen’s “Lennonism vs. Judaism” with a mixture of both disgust and surprise.
Early on I was disgusted as Ze’ev passed judgment on three Israeli born Hare Krishna’s he met at LAX airport. One of the Israelis, Ofer was criticizing Judaism and Ze’ev snidely remarks, “This from a guy shorn down to his cranium, with paint on his face, wrapped in linen and dancing to a mantra beat all day long in an airport.” Judging Ofer on his “different” appearance, not on anything Ofer actually said.
This cultural arrogance made clear that Ze’ev, like so many think that “western” style of fashion is “normal” and any divergence, abnormal. This all too common, disgustingly arrogant and disrespectful attitude (though Ze’ev will no doubt deny these obvious conclusions) really says it all.
Ze’ev then calls John Lennon’s killer a “fruitcake,” a term which bullies/cowards like Ze’ev generally reserve for homosexuals. Hurtful name-calling is something I expect from the many bullies/cowards of the Jewish and Christian communities. However it is something I’d like to have believed Reform Jews would reject, whatever Mr. Maghen’s excuse may be. Apparently I am mistaken, and now know to not necessarily expect different behavior from Reform Jews, than so many other arrogant white people (and yes, I am white).
Ze’ev quotes Leviticus 19:18 “Love your neighbor as yourself,” and falsely claims that Jesus and Rabbi Akiba placed this law as paramount. I know that Jesus placed God as paramount. Then again people like Ze’ev (and many Jews) are usually too smart to believe in God. Besides they’ve got religion (people and community). Who needs God? Leave that to the goyim. This explains how Ze’ev conveniently misquotes Jesus, just as he (like his and my ancestors) misunderstands Torah. I choose to admit my ancestors’ mistakes and work to correct them, as opposed to taking pride in and perpetuating their errors. Matthew 22:37-39 shows what Jesus did state as paramount, “’Love the Lord your God with all your heart and with all your soul and with all your mind.’ This is the first and greatest commandment. And the second is like it, ‘Love your neighbor as yourself.’” This is quite different than what Mr. Maghen stated. This puts life on a different level. One’s primary dependence is upon God. Frankly with the track record of the Jewish community (i.e. 6 million cluelessly massacred), I wouldn’t trust you folks to give me the correct time of day. This leaves trust in God a much more viable option.
Then Mr. Maghen makes some points with which I partially agree and partially disagree. From his approach I suspect such thinking would be foreign, as it is to many. Ze’ev, like so many, sees things in a black and white, all or nothing mentality. He will no doubt consider my nuanced approach “crazy,” and other belittling names just as he called those young Hare Krishna’s. However, I do not allow people like Mr. Maghen to impact my self-esteem nor stifle me, however innocent they may proclaim themselves to be.
When Ze’ev states, “Anyone who claims or aspires to love everybody the same simply has no idea what love means. Love that means anything distinguishes and prefers.” Much of that statement I would tend to agree with. I would wish to know the context of those claiming to “love everybody” however.
When Ze’ev concludes that quote by saying ‘“universal love” isn’t love at all.’ I’d say that this is reactionary and typically Jewish. Because certain non-Jewish groups overstate certain points, I all too often see a Jewish response which is reactionary in the other direction. For example, many Christians speak about Hell over and over and over. This is quite annoying. Next thing you know, we Jews don’t believe in Hell. Actually it seems “we” don’t even think about it. We’re just annoyed at hearing about it so much from certain Christians. We’ll show them and say just the opposite. Just to annoy them. All while living under their system. This is one example of why I am no longer Jewish, or any other religion. If people can insult my intelligence by dismissing the concept of Hell (or Heaven) because others over-emphasize the concept, then such people will not make any decisions in my life, including whether or not I am a Jew (or a Christian).
More of this egotism and brain-washing is displayed when Ze’ev states that by Jews keeping the Sabbath they are saying “I love this day more than any other day of the week.” Oh really, is he in their heads to determine what they are saying? The sad fact is that most Jews will say whatever their leaders put in their brain-washed heads. The sad fact is that many are keeping the Sabbath more as part of their egomaniacism, feeling that their relgion is better, and to avoid being ostracized, than anything to do with God. As for myself, I am simply resting on Shabbat. Whether I love or revere this day above others may be a logical conclusion, however it is erroneous. I don’t need to feel that my day of rest is better than others, nor than any other day. Shabbat simply is what it is. People like Ze’ev continually feel this need to say what is best and what is worst. Also conveniently, everything Ze’ev is associated with always turns out to be the best. This is egotism run amok and is all too prevalent and even encouraged in Jewish circles. I find it repulsive.
I don’t keep the Jewish Sabbath, I keep the Sabbath. I do not do so to feel superior or to be part of a community that can and would ostracize me for one or another inane reason. I do so to rest. I do so because there is only one seventh day of the week. It is very much in the spirit of John Lennon’s message in his beautiful song Imagine that I chose this path of seeking a universal truth. Discovering, much to my dismay, that much of this truth lies within Judaism as well as Christianity. Dismay because this meant having to deal with the egomaniacs and name-callers like Ze’ev Maghen. This meant trying to wrestle the truth that Maghen and his precious religions have mangled and distorted to divide and control. Well, looks like another one, like those Israeli Hare Krishna’s, has slipped through your mind-controlling and mind-numbing fingers, Ze’ev.
I not only imagine a world without religion, I have recently designed, display and sell two bumper stickers which very much reflect the message of John Lennon. It states in English with a matching one in Spanish, I Don’t Have A RELIGION I Have A GOD! Now that I have made my position clear for all to see, I have ironically been willing to join a temple for the first time in my life. I also found one, a Reform one at that, which has accepted and tolerates me. I belong to Beth Chayim Chaddashim in Los Angeles, the world’s first GLBT synagogue. This is a unique temple and contains some unique individuals. I am very much an individual, something most organized religious cults do not tolerate. This should change so that at least Jews can stop having people like Mr. Maghen speak for and represent them. Then maybe people in Hare Krishna linens with paint on their face will be accepted. Maybe they will also accept dreamers such as John Lennon. As he stated, he is “not the only one.”





